Marriage counseling isn’t only for those who have total trauma in their marriages. Sometimes all you need is one major disagreement to send you running to a counselor. Ours had to do with housekeeping. My husband likes a clean orderly, uncluttered, house. I on the other hand definitely want the house clean but a little bit of clutter doesn’t bother me all that much. I think that he is a fastidious, anal-retentive cleaning nut-case. He thinks I should be more, um, orderly. Picking a cat hair off the counter doesn’t bother me, but it drives him crazy. So, in essence, we are the “odd couple” of housekeeping.
Agreeing that our disagreement was putting a hitch in our otherwise convivial married life, I decided to seek the counsel of one of those people who basically tell you how to solve your problems. The problem was finding one.
I was hesitant to ask any friends for recommendations. You know how rumors start. (“Listen, did you know that Kristen and Alan are going for marriage counseling? Yeah. I know!! We thought they were such a happy couple, too! Boy! You never know about people, do you?”)
So I went about finding one in my usual non-orderly manner: I looked on-line for counselors in our area and found one with a nice sounding name, Dr. Aaron Bennings. Dr. Bennings, said his website, "has a innovative way of zoning in on the true reason for marital discord and distress". He didn’t do a whole lot to solve our cleaning problem, but he did bring a new relative into our lives.
We arrive early and walk past the receptionist’s desk, trying our best to give the “we-really-love-each-other-and-we’re-not-here-because-we-actually-need-counseling” impression, and go into the office to wait. Alan stands looking at the framed degrees on the wall and I hear him mutter something.
“What? Did you say something?” I ask this a bit sharply because he didn’t really want to come in the first place; he feels that if I would just be a little more concerned with being neater, we wouldn’t have a problem. And I feel he borders on obsessive-compulsive, is too concerned with cat hair, is……………, well you get the picture.
“I said,” he enunciates slowly and solemnly for my benefit, “Ph.D. You know what Ph.D. really means? Piled Higher and Deeper.” Oh boy! High comedy here!
He runs his finger along a book shelf and holds it up for me to see.
“And by the way, doesn’t anybody dust in here?”
I sigh. A comedian, I live with an obsessive-compulsive comedian. I’m on the verge of responding when the door opens and an overweight, semi-bald man, with his remaining hair in a ponytail walks through the door. Alan and I immediately sit on the couch and hold hands, acting like a loving, cute couple. We are like kids sitting in the principal’s office. I smile idiotically while Alan looks around the room. Probably checking for dust bunnies I think nastily.
The marriage counselor sits opposites us, crosses his legs, and takes out a pen and notebook. He taps his right ear and, after looking at us, asks who would like to tell him why we are here. I hesitate but Alan is preoccupied examining the wall, so leaning forward I decide to be brave and get right to the heart of our problem.
“Well, mostly, my reason, I guess, is because my husband is like Felix Unger.”
“Excuse me, he is like who?” says the counselor as he discreetly taps his ear.
“Unger, Felix……..” I say a little louder.
“Ah, he is like his uncle?”
“I’m sorry?”
“He exhibits traits you find disagreeable in his Uncle Felix?”
Alan, who has been studying the bookcase, suddenly says:
“Whose Uncle Felix?”
“Nobody’s Uncle Felix.” I say, turning to my husband.
“You feel his Uncle Felix is a nobody?” interjects the counselor That is interesting. Now why do you think that?”
“No, I don’t………It’s not his Uncle Felix, it’s…………..”
“Ah, then you’re saying that your husband reminds you of your Uncle Felix and that upsets you,” says Mr. Counselor. He turns to my husband.
“Alan, she obviously feels that you somehow remind her of her Uncle Felix whom she dislikes intensely. Did you know that?”
“You have an uncle named Felix?” asks Alan, roused from his contemplation of dust and clutter. “Was he at the wedding?”
“Whose wedding?” I ask confused.
“Our wedding. Because if he was there, I seriously don’t remember meeting him.”
“Listen,” I say to Alan, “if I had an Uncle Felix, don’t you think I’d remember?”
“Uncle Felix was at your wedding but you don’t remember?” interjects the counselor. “Do you have this problem often?” he asks me.
“What problem?”
“With remembering your uncle. Is your feeling of dislike so intense that you can completely forget he was in a room with you? That he was at your wedding reception? What happened between you and your Uncle Felix?”
“I have no Uncle named Felix,” I say adamantly.
“Ah! So you feel, in your mind, he does not exist! How interesting!”
“Hey!” says Alan suddenly, “Is that the uncle who borrowed your father’s SUV and accidentally set it on fire during a tail-gating party for his college fraternity? No wonder you want to forget him! He’s a real head case from what your father told me!”
“No, no, you’re thinking of my cousin Brian.” I turn to Alan. “Omigod! Did my father actually tell you that story? He usually doesn’t tell anybody about that! He didn’t speak to Brian for months!”
“So what did your uncle do after your cousin set the SUV on fire?” Alan asks.
“Which uncle?”
“Felix, Brian’s father.”
“I don’t have an Uncle Felix!”
The counselor taps his ear and interrupts us:
“Is there bad blood between your uncle and your father because of the car fire? Did it upset you that they weren’t speaking?”
“No there’s no bad blood because there isn’t any…”
“How many brothers and sisters does your father have?”
“One, only one brother, no sisters. I don’t see what that question has……..”
“If there’s no bad blood between your father and his only sibling, why do you have a hard time forgiving Uncle Felix? You did, after all, invite him to your wedding. You must have some liking for him. It isn’t healthy to keep all this pain inside.”
“What are you talking about?” I ask bewildered. “We’re here to discuss my problem with Alan and his problem with me!”
“Yes, because he reminds you of your uncle who burned up your poor father’s car and caused a rift in the family that has obviously lasted for years and left you distraught.”
“No one caused a rift in my family! And I’m not distraught, damn it! I’m a happy person; I come from a happy family! We’re the happiest family in the whole damn world! Call my parents and ask them, they’ll tell you damn it!”
The counselor studies me for a minute and then, very gently asks:
“Why won’t you discuss your intense hatred for Uncle Felix?”
“Because there is no Uncle Felix!” I shout.
The counselor scribbles something in his notebook.
“Let’s talk to Alan for a minute. Alan, how do you feel about your wife’s family disowning Uncle Felix? Does this impact your marriage?”
“Well, no, I didn’t think so because I never knew anything about it. But, now that you mention it, I never heard her father talk about Felix…”
“Because he doesn’t exist!!! Felix does not, in any way, shape, or form exist!!”
“Isn’t he Brian’s father?”
“No!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”
“Ah, now we are getting somewhere!” says the Ph.D. excitedly, tapping his ear.
“Brian doesn’t acknowledge Felix as his father because Felix never married his mother! Your father is angry about this paternal negligence and that is why Felix set your father’s car on fire!”
“That would explain a lot about your cousin Brian, honey,” says, Alan nodding knowingly.
“Listen to me,” I say with clenched teeth. “I do not have an Uncle Felix. My father does not have a brother named Felix. Brian’s father is not named Felix. There is no one in my entire family named Felix! Do you understand what I am saying? Felix, as a real man, does not exist!!”
“As a real man?!” repeats the counselor. “Now I see.”
I lean back, exhausted, on the couch and say, as an afterthought,
“Am I going crazy or what here?!”
Alan sits flabbergasted at my outburst. The counselor is furiously scribbling in his notebook and nodding his head. Finally, he looks at me and says firmly but gently:
“You are not crazy, Kristen. It is not your fault that your father hates his only brother, your Uncle Felix, because he didn’t marry Brian’s mother. How was your father to know that Felix couldn’t marry her because he wanted to have a sex-change operation! When your father found out, and strongly objected to this operation, in which his only brother would become his only sister, Felix, in a childish rage, set fire to your father’s car. A family issue like that can cause a lot of anger and it is this anger that is causing the problems in your marriage. You must forgive Uncle Felix and accept him as your aunt. Then, and only then, can you begin to work on your feeling that Alan is like your Uncle, who is now your Aunt Felix.”
I am stunned. No one speaks for about five minutes as the counselor studies us. Suddenly he turns to my husband and asks:
“Alan, is it the fact that Kristen feels you somehow may want to behave in a manner somewhat, uh, similar to her Uncle, now, Aunt Felix? May I assume that you are totally comfortable with your masculinity and that she shouldn’t be concerned about your sexual identity?”
“What?! Hey! Wait a minute! There’s nothing wrong with me! It’s Felix we’re talking about here! He’s the guy with all the problems!”
Alan sits up and glares at Dr. Ponytail. I gently touch Alan’s hand and whisper that, since there is no Uncle Felix, he shouldn’t get upset about resembling someone who is not real. He grips my hand, gives me a lopsided confused smile, and whispers back, “not a real what?”
“Not a real man,” I sigh.
“And I remind you of him?! Thanks a lot!”
“I give up!!”
The counselor closely watches our interaction.
“This is good, this is good. You two seem about to make a breakthrough. You are discussing the problem of Felix. Good, good.” The counselor is smiling and writing in his notebook.
“Now, Kristen. How do you think we can go about resolving this situation? Because it is apparent to me that the problem seems to be with you in this instance. You have a problem with Uncle, I’m sorry, Aunt Felix.”
“Gee, he, I mean she, kept the name Felix? That’s a horrible name even for a guy!” says Alan.
“I just told you there is no one named Felix!” I hiss.
The fancy Rolex on the counselor’s wrist is making gentle dinging sounds, the sign that our “50 minute hour” He checks his watch, taps his ear, and gets up extending his hand.
“I think, I really do, with all the convoluted familial relationship dynamics involved here that I would like to see you twice a week, at the same time. You need to be able to discuss the problem with each other and to role play exactly what has happened in the family. In fact we have to have both your father and Felix come in for one or two sessions after we have solved the anger issue. I think Felix needs to understand that the family will accept him, her, as she is. My secretary is out today. Call her tomorrow for your next appointment. This situation is serious!”
“But…,” I begin before realizing anything I say is an exercise in futility.
Alan waits by the door while I stop by the receptionist’s desk to give her our insurance card. As I turn away she calls to the counselor:
“Oh Doctor, wait a minute, before you go to your next session I have a message from your wife. She wants to know if your hearing aid is still losing volume and fading in and out. She's going to drop off a new battery for it later this morning and see if that helps.”
I nudge Alan on the way out the door.
“Did you hear that? No wonder he was so mixed up about Felix Unger. He didn’t hear what I said! His hearing aid was out! Honey? Alan?”
But “honey, Alan” is busy on his cell phone. He’s talking to my father. I hear him say,
“It went okay, I guess, but we didn’t get to talk about the cleaning problem. I know, I know, but it seems that there were other things bothering Kristen and that’s why I’m calling. Listen, sir? I know this is a sore subject with you but I need to ask you about your brother Felix……, Brian’s father? The transgender pyromaniac?”